Climate & Atmosphere: Permafrost Thaw
The Frozen Carbon Bomb That Climate Models Keep Getting Wrong
Beneath the Arctic tundra lies twice as much carbon as is currently in the atmosphere — and it's starting to wake up.
The Idea
Permafrost is ground that has remained frozen for at least two consecutive years, though much of it has been locked solid for thousands. It covers roughly a quarter of the Northern Hemisphere's land surface — vast stretches of Siberia, Alaska, Canada, and Tibet — and it holds an estimated 1.5 trillion tonnes of organic carbon: the partially decomposed remains of ancient plants, animals, and microbes that never fully rotted because the cold kept microbial activity suppressed. Here's what makes this genuinely alarming rather than merely concerning: as permafrost thaws, those ancient microbes wake up and resume their work. They begin breaking down the organic material, releasing carbon dioxide and methane — methane being roughly 80 times more potent as a greenhouse gas over a 20-year horizon. The release warms the atmosphere further, which thaws more permafrost, which releases more carbon. This is a feedback loop, not a linear process, and it operates largely independently of what humans do with their own emissions. What most climate models have historically underestimated — and some still do — is the abrupt thaw dynamic. Gradual surface thaw gets modelled reasonably well. But permafrost also collapses suddenly when ice-rich ground melts: hillsides slump, lakes drain overnight, land surfaces buckle into chaotic terrain called thermokarst. These abrupt events can release centuries' worth of stored carbon in a matter of years. The frozen ground isn't just thawing at the edges — in places, it's falling apart.
In the World
In August 2019, a team of researchers studying a stretch of permafrost in the Canadian Arctic returned to a site they had surveyed just 18 months earlier. What had been a stable hillside was gone. A slump — a retrogressive thaw slump, in the technical language — had carved away a section of ground roughly the size of several football pitches. The feature had advanced so rapidly that trees still stood upright at its edge, their roots suddenly exposed, the soil beneath them simply absent. Thaw slumps like this have been documented across the Arctic for decades, but their frequency and scale have accelerated sharply. Some in Siberia now stretch for kilometres. The Batagaika crater in Yakutia — sometimes called the 'gateway to the underworld' by locals — is a megaslump nearly a kilometre wide that has been expanding since the 1960s and is now growing faster than at any point in its recorded history. What these collapses expose is not just carbon, but time. Preserved mammoths, ancient viruses, and plant material from before the last ice age have all emerged from thawing permafrost. Scientists extracting ice cores in these regions describe the smell — a deep, loamy, anaerobic reek — as the scent of a world that has been sealed for millennia suddenly open to the air. It is, in a very literal sense, the past becoming present.
Why It Matters
The permafrost carbon feedback is one of the few large-scale climate mechanisms that operates on its own schedule, regardless of how quickly humanity decarbonises. This doesn't make action futile — far from it. Every fraction of a degree of warming avoided slows the rate of thaw and reduces how much carbon enters the cycle. But it does mean the climate system has dynamics that are not fully under human control, and that our models — the tools we use to make decisions about policy and timelines — may be systematically underestimating the warming to come. For a curious person trying to understand the climate conversation clearly, this is a crucial distinction: the difference between causes we can address and feedbacks we can only moderate. Permafrost thaw is a reminder that the climate isn't a dial we're turning — it's a system we disturbed, and some of what happens next will follow its own logic. Understanding that gap between 'what we emit' and 'what the Earth releases' is essential to thinking clearly about what net-zero targets actually do and don't guarantee.
A Question to Ponder
If a feedback loop like permafrost thaw can release carbon independent of human choices, how should that change the way we think about climate targets — and the honesty of the promises attached to them?
Get a new one of these every morning.
Start learning with Thinkable