Existentialism — Authenticity
The Role You're Playing Right Now (And Why Sartre Thought That Was a Problem)
Most people spend their lives performing a version of themselves they never consciously chose.
The Idea
Sartre had a name for the performance — bad faith. He described watching a Parisian waiter whose movements were just a little too waiter-like: the tray balanced with excessive precision, the posture a touch too attentive, the whole manner a flawless impersonation of Waiter. The man wasn't just doing a job. He was hiding inside one. Bad faith, for Sartre, isn't lying to others — it's a very specific act of lying to yourself. It means treating yourself as a fixed thing, a type, a role, when the uncomfortable truth is that you are radically free and therefore radically responsible. Human beings, unlike a chair or a stone, have no pre-given nature. Existence precedes essence — you showed up first, and meaning is something you make afterward. That's terrifying. So instead of facing the open horizon of choice, most of us reach for a ready-made identity: the responsible one, the cynic, the people-pleaser, the professional. We adopt scripts written by family, culture, or circumstance, and then mistake the script for ourselves. What makes authenticity so hard isn't that it requires courage in the dramatic sense — quitting jobs, moving cities. It's that it demands a constant, quiet willingness to notice when you're performing, and to ask whose approval that performance is actually for.
In the World
Simone de Beauvoir, Sartre's intellectual partner and a sharper writer on authenticity in many ways, tracked this problem across an entire life in her memoir 'Memoirs of a Dutiful Daughter.' She describes growing up as the perfectly obedient Catholic daughter in early twentieth-century Paris, a role she performed with such devotion that she mistook it for a personality. She was studious, pious, and well-behaved — not because she had examined any of it, but because the role was handed to her and she accepted it without question. The rupture came slowly, then suddenly: she began reading philosophy, befriended people her family disapproved of, and eventually found herself unable to pray — not because she decided to become an atheist, but because she noticed, with some shock, that she no longer believed. What de Beauvoir describes isn't rebellion for its own sake. It's closer to a patient excavation — digging down through layers of received expectation until she hit something that felt genuinely hers. She later argued that women in particular were handed especially thick scripts and then praised for performing them well. But the trap she identified isn't gendered — it's human. The scripts come in different forms for different people; the sedative effect is the same.
Why It Matters
Authenticity has been so thoroughly co-opted by self-help culture that the word itself is almost useless — it now tends to mean 'post whatever you feel like' or 'be unapologetically yourself,' which is advice with no content. The existentialist version is harder and more interesting. It doesn't promise that the real you is wonderful and just needs to be unleashed. It says the self is not a buried treasure but an ongoing project, one you're either engaging honestly or avoiding through habit and conformity. The practical question it opens up isn't 'who am I really?' but rather 'in this moment, am I choosing — or am I just executing a script?' That's a question worth sitting with not once, but regularly. It shows up in small things: how you respond to a question you're not sure you agree with, what you say you enjoy when someone asks, how you explain your work to people you want to impress. The moments of bad faith tend to be mundane, not dramatic. And that's exactly what makes them worth catching.
A Question to Ponder
Is there an identity or role you've been performing so consistently that you've stopped noticing it's a performance — and if so, what would it feel like to step out of it for just one conversation today?
Get a new one of these every morning.
Start learning with Thinkable