Mindfulness & Contemplation
When Watching Your Thoughts Makes Everything Worse
Mindfulness has quietly become the aspirin of modern psychology — prescribed for almost everything, and rarely questioned.
The Idea
The premise of mindfulness is elegant: observe your thoughts without judgment, and suffering loses its grip on you. Decades of research support real benefits — reduced rumination, lower cortisol, better emotional regulation. But somewhere between the monastery and the wellness app, a subtler truth got lost. Mindfulness is a tool, not a universal solvent, and for some people in some states, it makes things measurably worse. The phenomenon has a name in clinical literature: meditation-induced adverse effects. Studies, including a significant 2022 paper in PLOS ONE, found that over a quarter of regular meditators had experienced at least one negative effect — anxiety, depersonalisation, emotional overwhelm, or a disturbing heightening of intrusive thoughts. These weren't rare outliers. They were ordinary people doing ordinary mindfulness practice. The mechanism isn't mysterious. Mindfulness asks you to turn toward your inner experience. If that experience contains unprocessed trauma, a fragile sense of self, or a mind already prone to over-monitoring its own states, 'turning toward' can mean flooding. You're not watching thoughts like clouds — you're opening a door you weren't equipped to open alone. This doesn't mean mindfulness is dangerous. It means the breathless, one-size-fits-all evangelism around it has outpaced the nuance. Context matters enormously: who is practicing, what they're carrying, and whether present-moment awareness is actually what they need right now.
In the World
In 2014, Willoughby Britton, a neuroscientist at Brown University, launched what became known as the 'Dark Night Project' — a systematic effort to document the difficult, destabilising experiences that meditators rarely discuss publicly. She had personal reasons: Britton herself had experienced a prolonged, disorienting episode following an intensive retreat, one that disrupted her sleep and sense of reality for months. What she found when she interviewed long-term practitioners was striking. Experiences ranged from mild discomfort to full psychiatric crises — and most subjects reported that no teacher, no retreat centre, and no mainstream mindfulness guide had warned them such outcomes were possible. The culture around meditation, particularly in its secular Western form, had developed a powerful blind spot. Britton's work is careful to avoid alarmism. Her point isn't that meditation is harmful but that the context matters enormously — the intensity of practice, the guidance available, and crucially, what the practitioner is bringing with them. A ten-minute app session and a ten-day silent retreat are not the same thing, and the research supporting 'mindfulness' often refers to highly controlled clinical protocols that bear little resemblance to how most people actually practice. The broader implication is worth sitting with: our enthusiasm for any powerful intervention tends to smooth over its edges. And a practice designed to cultivate honesty about experience deserves, at minimum, honesty about its limits.
Why It Matters
If you've tried mindfulness and found it helpful, none of this should unsettle you. But if you've ever sat with your breath and felt worse — more anxious, more trapped in your own head, more aware of everything you'd rather not feel — you deserve to know that this isn't failure. It may be feedback. The more useful reframe isn't 'mindfulness works' or 'mindfulness doesn't work' — it's asking what you actually need in a given moment. Sometimes that is present-moment awareness. Sometimes it's movement, distraction, connection, or structured problem-solving. Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, behavioural activation, and other evidence-based approaches offer different angles on the same terrain, and they work better for some people in some situations. There's also something worth noting about how we consume wellness ideas generally: we tend to adopt them wholesale before the nuance has caught up. The smarter habit is to treat any practice — however well-researched — as a hypothesis about yourself, not a prescription. Watch what it actually does. Adjust accordingly.
A Question to Ponder
Is there something you keep returning to because it's genuinely helping, or because stepping back from it would feel like giving up on yourself?
Get a new one of these every morning.
Start learning with Thinkable