Existentialism: Sartre and Radical Freedom
You Are Condemned to Choose — Even When You Don't
Sartre's most unsettling claim isn't that God is dead — it's that you have no excuse.
The Idea
Most of us quietly believe that our lives have been shaped by forces beyond our control — our upbringing, our circumstances, our personality, the era we were born into. Sartre doesn't dispute that these forces exist. What he disputes is that they determine you. His concept of radical freedom holds that human beings are, at every moment, entirely responsible for what they make of what has been made of them. There is no fixed human nature to hide behind, no essence that precedes your existence and lets you off the hook. You are not a stone or a hammer — objects whose purpose is baked in before they arrive in the world. You arrive first, and then you create what you are through every choice you make. The terrifying corollary is that not choosing is also a choice. Staying in the job you hate, the relationship that diminishes you, the city that no longer fits — these are not neutral defaults. They are active decisions, renewed every single day. Sartre called the refusal to own this 'bad faith': the very human tendency to pretend we are more determined, more fixed, more cornered than we actually are. Bad faith is comfortable. It converts freedom — which is vertiginous and heavy — into the simpler story of 'I had no choice.' But for Sartre, that story is always, at some level, a lie we tell ourselves to escape the weight of being free.
In the World
In the winter of 1940, Sartre was a prisoner of war in a German stalag. He had been captured during the fall of France, stripped of rank and routine, surrounded by barbed wire and uncertainty. By almost any measure, his freedom had been extinguished. And yet it was precisely here — in one of the least free situations imaginable — that his thinking about radical freedom crystallised. Rather than collapse into passivity, Sartre organised a clandestine Christmas performance for his fellow prisoners. He wrote a play, 'Bariona,' and staged it in the camp. His argument, which he would later develop in 'Being and Nothingness,' was that even under occupation — literal or metaphorical — the inner act of interpretation, refusal, or meaning-making remains yours. The Nazis could control his body. They could not control what he made of captivity. This is not toxic positivity dressed in philosophical language. Sartre wasn't saying suffering is fine because attitude is everything. He was making a harder and more precise claim: that even within extreme constraint, the human consciousness retains the capacity to choose its orientation toward its situation. You may not be able to change your circumstances. You always choose how you stand in relation to them. His prisoner's play was not escapism — it was a lived demonstration that even in a stalag, you remain the author of your own existence.
Why It Matters
What Sartre gives you on a Monday morning — or any morning — is not comfort, but clarity. Most of the weight we carry isn't from circumstances themselves but from the story that circumstances have chosen us, rather than the other way around. When you realise that staying put is as much a choice as moving, that silence is as deliberate as speaking, that 'I can't' usually means 'I've decided not to' — something shifts. This can feel like an unbearable burden. Sartre called it anguish, and he didn't think you should suppress it. The anguish of freedom is appropriate — it means you're taking your life seriously. But it also opens something up. If there is no predetermined version of you that you're failing to live up to or waiting to become, then the project of your life is genuinely open. Not infinitely — context matters, history matters — but more open than bad faith allows you to believe. The question isn't whether you're free. For Sartre, you already are, inescapably. The question is whether you're honest about it.
A Question to Ponder
Where in your life are you calling a choice a constraint — and what would change if you owned it as a decision?
Get a new one of these every morning.
Start learning with Thinkable