Globalisation & Trade
The Tax Nobody Voted For: Why Tariffs Hit Your Wallet, Not the Exporter's
Every time a government announces a tariff, it claims the other country will pay — and every time, the data says the same thing: you will.
The Idea
There is a persistent and convenient fiction in trade politics: that tariffs are a bill sent to foreign exporters. The legal mechanics seem to support this. When a container of goods arrives at a port, it is the domestic importer — the company that bought the goods from abroad — who writes the cheque to customs. The foreign manufacturer, sitting in another country, pays nothing directly. So far, so reasonable. But economics cares about ultimate incidence, not legal formality. The real question is: who ends up worse off once prices, wages, and profits adjust? There are three candidates — the foreign exporter, the domestic importer, or the consumer at the end of the chain — and their relative pain depends entirely on market power and price sensitivity. In theory, a foreign exporter desperate to maintain market share might cut their prices to absorb the tariff, shielding importers and consumers. This almost never happens at scale. What the evidence consistently shows is the opposite: foreign producers keep their prices steady, importers absorb some cost initially (squeezing their own margins), and over six to twelve months that cost travels down the chain to ordinary buyers. The tariff functions, in practice, as a consumption tax — applied broadly, but felt unevenly. And crucially, it is a consumption tax that nobody debated, voted on, or openly designed.
In the World
The 2025 round of US tariffs — the most sweeping in generations, with the average effective rate reaching its highest level since 1947 — produced a natural experiment economists had been waiting years for. The results, confirmed by multiple independent teams, are remarkably consistent. Researchers at the Kiel Institute for the World Economy found that US importers and consumers bore roughly 96 percent of the tariff burden, with foreign exporters absorbing almost nothing. A separate analysis by economists Gopinath and Neiman, published in 2026, estimated that around 92 percent of the tariffs passed directly into the prices that US importers paid. Researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that by February 2026, the tariffs had contributed approximately 2.9 percentage points to consumer goods inflation — and that without the tariffs, prices for many of those goods would have actually fallen slightly. The price effect was not instant. In the early months, importers swallowed the cost rather than pass it on, perhaps betting the tariffs were temporary. But by roughly seven months after implementation, studies found pass-through to consumer prices was near-complete. Goods from China saw the sharpest increases — roughly double the price rise seen for goods from other countries by the end of 2025. Then a further twist arrived in February 2026, when the US Supreme Court ruled that the emergency powers law used to impose the broadest tariffs did not authorise them. Many of the highest rates were replaced by a lower baseline surcharge — illustrating how quickly the policy landscape can shift, even as the underlying economic logic stays constant.
Why It Matters
Understanding tariff incidence is not an abstract exercise. It changes who you think is bearing the cost of trade policy — and it reveals something uncomfortable about how that cost is distributed. Tariffs are, structurally, a regressive tax. Lower-income households spend a larger share of their income on goods — food, clothing, footwear, household products — many of which are imported or compete with imports. The Yale Budget Lab found that the burden of the 2025 tariffs, expressed as a share of income, fell on the lowest-income households at roughly three times the rate it fell on the highest-income households. In absolute amounts, wealthier households paid more; as a proportion of what they had, poorer households paid far more. This matters for how you read political arguments about trade. When a government says a tariff will be paid by another country, that claim has now been tested repeatedly, across different tariff regimes and different trading partners, and the answer is consistently the same. Domestic buyers pay. The foreign exporter mostly does not. Knowing this, you can be a sharper reader of economic policy — and a more sceptical one. The next time a politician announces a tariff as a cost-free act of economic strength, you now know exactly who to look at when the bill arrives.
A Question to Ponder
If the costs of tariffs fall mainly on domestic consumers rather than foreign exporters, why does the political appeal of tariffs remain so durable — and what does that tell us about how economic pain gets attributed?
One reader's Thinkable for Finance Friday — a random draw from the library.
Start learning with Thinkable